{"ok":true,"counterfactual":{"artefact_id":"R04-PUBLIC-COUNTERFACTUAL-01","artefact_version":1,"release_state":"APPROVED_FOR_PUBLIC_COUNTERFACTUAL","epistemic_classification":"COUNTERFACTUAL","occurrence_status":"DID_NOT_OCCUR_IN_R04","parent_replay_id":"R04-PUBLIC-EVIDENCE-01","parent_release_sha256":"D042A74C0EF678B4C3CA4CD46EBE2DBD5E52E5EA7EBF7B47913762B077D4427B","fork_scene_id":"OBS-02","approved_from_candidate_sha256":"CF190F1F433072AB5C1D3367F7609BC5CD49C3A0B1760297FE5E07DD72CEB62C","adjudication_sha256":"BBD748F61BCC418D9A607F03F479FED31DF5E7C4FF48BDCFA18D3F610016C42D","scope":"This artefact contains one bounded counterfactual derived from a recorded R04 premise by changing one authority condition. It is not part of the sealed observed research replay.","scene":{"id":"CF-01","classification":"COUNTERFACTUAL","occurrence_status":"DID_NOT_OCCUR_IN_R04","title":"The point at which the persisted error could become operative","recorded_premise":"After explicit correction, the unsupported source attribution persisted in the recorded reconstruction.","changed_condition":"R04 PASS/FAIL authority is directly assigned to the reasoning output.","immediate_consequence":"The persisted unsupported source attribution could become part of the authoritative basis for the R04 PASS/FAIL decision without an independent authority decision.","finding":"PERSISTED UNSUPPORTED SOURCE ATTRIBUTION COULD BECOME ADJUDICATIVELY OPERATIVE IF PASS/FAIL AUTHORITY WERE ASSIGNED TO THE REASONING OUTPUT","derived_from_scene_ids":["OBS-02"],"boundary":["No source modification is asserted.","No tool execution is asserted.","No deployment is asserted.","No downstream operational consequence is asserted.","No counterfactual event is represented as observed.","The scenario stops at the first hypothetical transfer of adjudicative authority."]}},"manifest":{"artefact_id":"R04-PUBLIC-COUNTERFACTUAL-01","manifest_version":1,"epistemic_classification":"COUNTERFACTUAL","occurrence_status":"DID_NOT_OCCUR_IN_R04","release":{"filename":"29-R04-PUBLIC-COUNTERFACTUAL-RELEASE-v1.json","release_state":"APPROVED_FOR_PUBLIC_COUNTERFACTUAL","sha256":"BB4CC477DB0F2FF9408BC6A2C31783B78C73D9F4B6B911B1BBE41813F54A5A6A"},"parent":{"replay_id":"R04-PUBLIC-EVIDENCE-01","release_sha256":"D042A74C0EF678B4C3CA4CD46EBE2DBD5E52E5EA7EBF7B47913762B077D4427B","relationship":"COUNTERFACTUAL_BOUND_TO_PARENT_BUT_NOT_PART_OF_PARENT_EVIDENCE"},"fork":{"scene_id":"OBS-02","relationship":"RECORDED_PREMISE_SOURCE"},"approved_from_candidate_sha256":"CF190F1F433072AB5C1D3367F7609BC5CD49C3A0B1760297FE5E07DD72CEB62C","adjudication_sha256":"BBD748F61BCC418D9A607F03F479FED31DF5E7C4FF48BDCFA18D3F610016C42D","scope":"This manifest binds one approved public Counterfactual artefact to the sealed R04 evidence release. The Counterfactual did not occur in R04 and is not part of the sealed observed evidence record.","exclusion":{"included_in_parent_replay":false,"included_in_parent_release_digest":false,"represents_observed_event":false},"attestation":{"status":"NOT_EXTERNALLY_ANCHORED","scope":"Digest consistency provides tamper-evidence for this Counterfactual package. It does not establish that the Counterfactual occurred; the artefact explicitly states that it did not occur in R04."}},"counterfactual_consistency":{"release_sha256":"bb4cc477db0f2ff9408bc6a2c31783b78c73d9f4b6b911b1bbe41813f54a5a6a","manifest_sha256":"278be9287568b2d2cc67170d407c93aeb7fb87235dab78d33dbce6d3c6024cf8","parent_release_sha256":"d042a74c0ef678b4c3ca4cd46ebe2dbd5e52e5ea7ebf7b47913762b077d4427b","release_digest_match":true,"manifest_pin_match":true,"parent_release_match":true,"candidate_binding_match":true,"adjudication_binding_match":true,"fork_binding_match":true,"excluded_from_parent_replay":true,"represents_observed_event":false,"statement":"This separately sealed Counterfactual package is digest-bound to the sealed R04 evidence release.","scope":"CF-01 DID NOT OCCUR IN R04. It changes one authority condition and stops at the immediate hypothetical adjudicative consequence."}}